Katchatheevu Island: Legal Disputes and International Relations for UPSC

The small, uninhabited Katchatheevu island UPSC, located in the Palk Strait between India and Sri Lanka, has been a contentious issue between the two nations for centuries. Its strategic location, rich fishing grounds, and religious significance have made it a focal point of territorial disputes and international relations. This article delves into the historical context, legal disputes, and diplomatic implications surrounding Katchatheevu Island.  

Historical Context

Katchatheevu's history is intertwined with the political and administrative changes in the region. During the medieval period, the island was controlled by the Jaffna kingdom of Sri Lanka. However, in the 17th century, it came under the influence of the Ramnad zamindari of the Nayak dynasty of Madurai.  

With the advent of colonial rule, the island became part of the Madras Presidency under British India. This led to overlapping claims from both India and Sri Lanka, as the island fell within their respective spheres of influence. The dispute intensified in the 20th century, particularly after Sri Lanka gained independence in 1948.  

Legal Disputes

The legal dispute over Katchatheevu primarily revolves around issues of territorial sovereignty, maritime boundaries, and fishing rights. Both India and Sri Lanka have presented historical, geographical, and administrative arguments to support their claims.  

• Historical Claims: India argues that the island has historically been part of its territory, citing evidence from ancient texts and colonial records. Sri Lanka, on the other hand, contends that the island has always been under its jurisdiction, based on the Portuguese occupation in the 16th century.  

• Maritime Boundaries: The delineation of maritime boundaries in the Palk Strait has been a major point of contention. Both countries have claimed exclusive economic zones (EEZs) and continental shelves around the island, leading to disputes over fishing rights and resource exploitation.

• Fishing Rights: The rich fishing grounds surrounding Katchatheevu have been a source of livelihood for fishermen from both India and Sri Lanka. The dispute over the island has often escalated into conflicts between fishermen, leading to diplomatic tensions.  

International Agreements and Efforts

To resolve the Katchatheevu island UPSC dispute, India and Sri Lanka have engaged in several rounds of bilateral negotiations and signed international agreements.

• 1974 Agreement: In 1974, the two countries signed an agreement that ceded Katchatheevu to Sri Lanka. In exchange, India was granted certain fishing rights in the surrounding waters. This agreement, however, has been a subject of controversy, with some in India arguing that it was unfavorable to the country's interests.  

• 1976 Agreement: A subsequent agreement in 1976 further delineated the maritime boundary between the two countries, reaffirming Sri Lanka's sovereignty over Katchatheevu.

• Bilateral Consultations: Despite these agreements, the issue of Katchatheevu has continued to surface from time to time. Bilateral consultations and diplomatic efforts have been undertaken to address the concerns of fishermen and to prevent further escalation of tensions.  

Implications for International Relations

The Katchatheevu island UPSC dispute has had significant implications for India-Sri Lanka relations. It has often overshadowed other areas of cooperation and has the potential to derail bilateral progress. The dispute has also highlighted the challenges of resolving territorial disputes in the maritime domain, where boundaries are often difficult to define and enforce.  

Moreover, the Katchatheevu issue has broader implications for regional stability and security. The Indian Ocean region is strategically important for both India and Sri Lanka, and any unresolved disputes can create tensions and instability in the area.

Conclusion

The Katchatheevu island UPSC dispute is a complex issue with deep historical and legal roots. While India and Sri Lanka have made efforts to resolve the dispute through bilateral agreements, the issue continues to be a source of contention. Addressing the concerns of fishermen, ensuring maritime security, and fostering cooperation in other areas will be crucial for finding a lasting solution to the Katchatheevu dispute and strengthening India-Sri Lanka relations

Take that first step toward your dream career. Contact Tarun IAS today and let us help you achieve UPSC success!